The X(itter) Renaissance That Really Isn’t a Thing

Every once and a while I see something bubble up on social media claiming there are masses of users flocking back to Xitter (what I call the site formerly know as Twitter, the x pronounced as ‘sh’). Well, actually what happens is that I occasionally get on Bluesky or Threads and see people making fun of the idea that there is some mass return to Xitter. So I decided to look into it and see if I am missing out on something.

First, looking around at Bluesky, it all seems the same. The people that were active there are still active. It is a robust space with a lot of discussion happening, even despite the fact that I have been lazy in following people back (sorry about that… still). From what I can see, Bluesky is not dying at all. I don’t really do other services enough to know if there is a difference or not, so I can’t comment about Threads, Mastodon, Signal, etc.

After a quick check to see if my Xitter account still works (somehow it does), and then closing out a mountain of scam notifications from the service itself (how many showers do people have to take after each visit? Yuck)… I look at my feed. Still deadsville. A few people that never left are still hanging on (I get it, you didn’t want to cede ground to the other side, wanted to stay and fight, etc. No judgement from me on that). No real new activity that I can see. Maybe a few people still doing POSSE finally figure out how to get their posts to go there as well? Is this the “flocking” I have heard of?

But the people still on Xitter seem to be convinced there is a flocking:

Saying the entire world got rich is… pretty out of touch with reality. And the attempted insult about only arguing about Ai and politics? Well, there was a HUGE political upheaval (blue tsunami) not long after this post, so maybe that wasn’t a waste of time?

The education people on Xitter are also buying into this return as well:

I’m not sure what counts as a “viable option,” but I can still pop into both Bluesky and Threads after being away for a long time and get into some great conversations on all kinds of topics. Seems there have been several viable options for a while. Or maybe things only count as “viable” if they are big and popular with lots of participants? That’s never really been my problem for sure.

But what about some kind of proof that people are flocking back? It seems to mostly be a bunch of “trust me bro, I saw hundreds” articles like this one by John Gruber. Gruber seems to really hate that people don’t like Ai but like to talk politics. His assessment of Bluesky is the opposite of mine, and probably says more about who he follows and what he posts than the actual state over there. He claims that “the culture on X today is remarkably friendly and inclusive” which… huh? I can spend 2 minutes verifying this is not true at all. He complains about Ai-haters jumping into replies on Bluesky, but seems fine with all of the White Supremacists still massively active on Xitter? Yikes. I’m still seeing them everywhere on my quick dip back over there.

Then he makes this head-scratching statement:

“If you returned from exile on a desert island and took a look at X today for the first time in a year, you might reasonably guess that Elon Musk got bored and sold it while you were away. I do think he got bored micromanaging it, but the rank muskiness that permeated the platform after he took over is — for now, at least — gone.”

I mean, I did just that (returned after being gone for a long while). I was immediately hit with Xitter trying to get my phone number, my bank details, trying to get me to choose from multiple paid tiers, and much more “muskiness.” Not to mention all of the hateful stuff still very much everywhere in the comments. Does he not realize all of this bears the distinct scent of Musk trying to get more money and control over everyone?

Speaking of head-scratchers: some ways of looking at this issue are kind of…. well…

Some of the people making commentary on social media don’t even understand how it works. “Ceded the floor?” That has really big “those tubes can be filled” energy. There is no one “floor” on social media. There are an infinite number of “floors” that go to who ever people want to give attention to at the moment. Someone could start an account tomorrow, post a thought that goes viral, and have thousands and thousands of people follow them overnight. There is no “floor” to “cede” on Xitter or anywhere else online. That is an old school outdated academic gatekeeper mindset.

If you are wondering where all of this weirdness about flocking back to Xitter came from, I think this article on The Verge by Gaby Del Valle pulls apart the argument nicely: The Midterms Proved Once And For All That X is Not Real Life. It probably also sheds light on why people on Xitter think that the current version of Ai still has a future in a world that is mostly rejecting it.

While Del Valle’s article correctly points out that “Most of the American public isn’t on X,” it also proposes some theories about what is happening to those that are still there:

“(JD) Vance, especially, is a creature of X…. White House aides, department employees, and Hill staffers are stewing in the same ecosystem. Writer John Ganz has termed this phenomenon ‘groyperfication,’ after followers of influencer Nick Fuentes, who call themselves groypers.”

The idea that the Xitter users quoted above and others are possibly subject to groyperfication is… not a good thing. So why are so many education people on Xitter so convinced that Ai is still a good thing, or that there is some kind of “flocking back” to Xitter is happening?

“The answer lies in the algorithmic nature of social media, X especially. If you interact with even one post about a relatively niche topic — say, genderbent Harry Potter fanfiction — the algorithm will feed you post after post after post about the same thing…. you may even delude yourself into thinking the issue clogging up your feed is something people just can’t stop talking about.”

To take this a step further: if you are only re-posting things about how people are flocking back to Xitter, or how Ai is going to revolutionize the world, that is what you are going to start seeing more of in your feed. Not to mention that Elon Musk is massively pro-Ai and Xitter, and is more than likely further skewing the algorithms behind the scene. If you only glance at criticisms of Ai and Xitter (or ignore them altogether), you won’t see much of them. Then you get things like this:

This is an example of how some people are not only discussing Ai as if it will eliminate the need for jobs (no actual real-world trend is going in that direction), but fantasizing about a reality where governments and business will still provide for us without jobs (not happening in any real country in any reality). How does discussing something that is not going to happen, under a government structure that does not exist, help with educational issues today?

One of the threads weaving through all of these quotes and examples is a hatred of politics and talking about politics. Which I get. But if you can’t see that education and technology are political now (even though, yes, they should never have been), then you are the one that has ceded any meaningful “floor.” Politicians have unfortunately drug education into politics. CEOs of big tech companies (and even worse, Ed-Tech companies) have embedded themselves in politics. The solutions for the problems that education faces are now political. Protecting “we the people” from the abusive side of business and tech has always been political. I’m just old enough to remember all of the people who got frustrated with “activists” that kept talking about car safety requirements and pollution limits and those kinds of things. It seems all of this talk about a Xitter Renaissance is just people wanting to avoid dealing with the consequences of the shiny things they wish were taking over the world.

Ai: The Last Stand of the Ed-Tech™ Grifters

Sal Khan is going to revolutionize Higher Ed. Again. I’m not really going to write about what the idea is here – some are referring to him as “Serial Failure Sal Khan,” so I doubt it will catch on.

People are (rightly so) connecting this “new” idea to past ideas that were supposedly going to revolutionize education: blogs, MOOCs, virtual worlds, learning analytics, Ai, and so on. Ed-Tech™ (as an industry) is littered with tools and designs that failed to revolutionize education.

And yes, I know that some will balk at the idea of constraining Ed-Tech™ to just the companies that sell specific technology to institutions. I get it. There is more to the field than companies. Ed-Tech™ companies don’t care that they are selling education tools anymore than the companies selling parking management technology or food service technology care about parking or food. When I go to visit friends that still work at universities, the systems and technology I use to park there, to eat a meal on campus, to check into their building, etc are occasionally or constantly changing. That technology is sold by companies that don’t really care to be called parking-tech or what ever. Some feel it is a stretch to put the “ed” in Ed-Tech™ – I get it. They are selling surveillance, or grade management, or tracking systems, or other things.

Most of my courses for over a decade were taught through open-source tools. I know there is open education, indie ed-tech, open-source tools, etc. One of my degrees is technically in “Educational Technology,” so I get that there is a lot more to educational technology that just Ed-Tech™ companies.

But those companies are so dominant that you can’t ignore their effect. Plus, you really don’t have “parking-tech thought leaders” out there telling everyone the newest phone app payment method is going to revolutionize the “parking by phone app” world. So that is why I use Ed-Tech™ – I’m not trying to include that local professor hacking and extending open source tools to deliver their course outside of the system. There are powerful, dominant companies out there trying to mold education into their version of “learning” through technology – which is more than a parking technology company trying to get institutions to upgrade to the latest version of their tech.

However, I also disagree with people referring to MOOCs, blogs, virtual worlds as “failed trends.” Those tools still exist to some degree today. Not to mention that they were created well before they became a trend, often by people that usually (although not always) scoffed at the later hype.

Technically speaking, these tools were not the failure. The thought leaders that hyped them were the failures.

For example, MOOCs are credited to George Siemens and Stephen Downes, neither of whom proclaimed these ideas were going to revolutionize education. It was (surprise surprise) Sal Khan that claimed there would be something like 10 universities serving MOOCs to millions of students each. The disconnect between original MOOCs and hype-trend MOOCs was so stark that people came up with terms for each. Remember xMOOCs and cMOOCS? Oh, and MOOCs are still around believe it or not. The actual failure was that of thought leaders that repeated Khans outrageous claims with a straight faces.

While it still might be too early to call Ai a “failed” trend – the numbers are still not good. Just from this week alone, the research is not promising. Workplace surveys are showing that only 13% of the work staff use Ai daily and only 28% use it weekly while at work. Those numbers are only up 1% and 2% from last year, respectively. While 2 in 3 say they are more productive with Ai, deeper dives show that on average employees waste nearly 8 hours (an entire work day) per week fixing Ai outputs (what some cheerfully refer to as “prompt engineering” as if it is a good thing). Just like other research has shown, Ai makes employees feel more productive when they actually are not.

The effectiveness of Ai in education is still not looking good, either. Research is starting to show that there is a “growing body of research suggesting that extensive AI use can distort and dampen users’ thinking and independence.” It also turns out that while there are hundreds of published articles that discuss Ai, very few are about good quality research. This review of K-12 literature, for example, found that “as of October 2025 the Ai Hub for Education Research Repository contained over 800 academic papers relevant to Ai in K-12 education” but “only a small subset (20 papers) produce strong causal evidence.” Those papers generally found that “Ai improves performance with access but when assessed independently without Ai support, effects are mixed” and that “Ai tools can alleviate students’ cognitive burden and foster positive experiences in learning, but can be at the expense of deeper thinking.”

So with the numbers not looking good, you have to wonder why so many are continuing to push the narrative that “Ai is inevitably going to revolution education”?

(And yes, it is a bit head scratching that some who were frustrated at their trend being declared the “future of education” have now jumped on the “Ai is the future of education” train.)

When you look at past hyped trends, there was always something else on the horizon (there was even a report about said horizon). When blogs were being touted as the future of education, there were things like Web3.0 (remember that?) and virtual worlds being developed. When virtual worlds were hot for a half minute, there were MOOCs coming up. After MOOCs, there was learning analytics. I think there was a blip of virtual reality? I probably blinked and missed it. After that was Ai. In fact, Ai was always in the background as something coming at some point.

But what is there after Ai?

I would contend that there really isn’t anything, and that is why the thought leaders and Ed-Tech™ companies are digging in so fiercely on something that is ‘meh’ at best, damaging at worst. Sure, some would say agentic Ai or autonomous robots or things like that are next – but all of those are technically just extensions of Ai.  Without Ai becoming a major thing, those ideas don’t happen either. Ai is (in my best guess, at least) the last stand of the Ed-Tech™ grift, so they have to make it work.

Sure, there will be trends after this. And there will be “innovations” in the surveillance market as well. But what “new” technology – especially one that will “revolutionize” education – will they be able to pivot to after Ai fades? Ai has kind of been considered the pinnacle of computer technology for decades. So that is (to me at least) why you see the thought leaders and companies trying so hard to make it work. Even though it isn’t. We can only hope that the trend will truly die before we run out of water and resources to keep humans running in the aftermath.

Or maybe this is why we see Khan now coming up with an idea that apparently rolls together past trends like MOOCs, Google, and alternative certifications: the future trends in education will just be remixed past trends. Is Sal Khan the first in a line of people trying to be the bubble and squeak of education since he knows there is nothing after Ai? In some ways, that sounds worse than just getting another new hot trend to change the face of education. (With apologies to those that can make really amazing bubble and squeak.)

Most People Don’t Need a “GenAi for Dummies” Book Anymore

I won’t apologize that this post won’t be a breathe of fresh air in the Ai conversation (although I do get why people want that). I am an Ai skeptic and I don’t hide that fact from anyone. Some things in this world are worth dividing over. I know people are tired of division and sides that everyone takes. It would be pretty easy as a white dude for me to sigh something about everyone taking a side and just accepting my Ai overlords like many do – but I also know there are many people that don’t have the luxury of avoiding sides. They are forced on a side just for being who they were born to be.

So, yes, I keep going back to the same old, same old Ai skeptic / critic / hater / whatever you want to call it side again and again because so many people that are harmed by Ai don’t have a choice to be on that side, or to even avoid either side. There is nothing special about my stance – it should be the baseline for most people: join with the vulnerable in fighting harm and injustice.

Yes, yes, I  know: not everything is that simple. I’m a huge believer in embracing complexity. But I also acknowledge that not everything has to be complex.

Or I could put it this way: the complexity I live with is that I don’t want to contribute to the problems that Ai is causing, but since Ai is almost everywhere these days, I don’t have that choice. I have to know how Ai works in order to know where it is in order to avoid it (or mitigate it’s effects as much as possible). But knowing how Ai works is not the same as actively, regularly using it.

This is what so many Ai Cheerleaders and Ai Both-sides-ers get wrong about Ai critics: we do know Ai. We don’t need a new guide to prompting better. We figured out that better prompting gets better results (but still not good results too often) about 30 seconds into our first time. And writing better prompts isn’t hard for many, especially those in academia that had to write papers constantly for years and multiple degrees.

I have seen well-meaning people get attacked for offering new “GenAi for Dummies” guides. Some of the attacks are pretty vicious and I truly wish that didn’t happen (and yes, I can say that while still disagreeing with the decision to create the guides in the first place). People are a couple of years and thousands of mansplaining hours into being told they just aren’t smart enough to figure out what is basically an autocomplete program (yes, I know Ai is a it more complex than prediction / autocomplete / etc – but that is technically what people are doing with prompting even if the underlying process is complex). Yes, they are smart enough. Please consider that most people that don’t like Ai are not simply in the “prompt harder!” demographic. I’m not justifying the vicious attacks of some, but I see where the anger comes from. Not all pushback is angry attacks, either.

I noticed this article in the Wall Street Journal about an Ai program that helps doctors write responses to patients: “After trying it for a few weeks, doctors said the drafts weren’t helpful and required too much rewriting.” This response to the article on Bluesky (the author set the post to only be read by those logged in to Bluesky, so you will have to go there to read it) is what so many of us say about these tools: yes, we have tried them.

Believe it or not, I do try to get out and talk to people that work with Ai. I try to make sure to talk to people that aren’t white men, mainly because they are the least likely ones to be harmed by Ai. I sat down and ate with someone that works at a very large tech firm here in my area. What they told me about their working conditions with Ai was frightening.

Like many companies of this size, they have an internal Ai solution for their specific field, as well as access to Copilot and other Ai services. They have a dashboard that tracks usage of their Ai tool, and additionally they have made overall Ai usage a requirement of work. Refusing to use Ai of any kind will become and HR and possibly a “reassignment issue.” I know that sounds pretty barbaric, but it is more common than you would realize in larger companies: use Ai or else.

Employees are told that the Ai-tracking dashboard is not punitive, just informational. However, the employee I spoke to had already gotten in trouble with multiple upper level leaders for not using their internal Ai. The kicker is that the internal Ai is designed for a completely different position than the employees works in. Yet they were called out publicly and harshly for not using it. This employee used it on the spot for a nonsense task, and then got praised.

However, that usage somehow did not register correctly and the employee still got flack for “not using” the internal Ai. In fact, several Ai-driven dashboards were not recording information properly. The employee had to have a long, contentious meeting with the upper level admin in charge of the dashboards to point out the problems, and it took a lot of back and forth to break through the guy’s confidence to make him see that it was not collecting data correctly.

On top of this, even when using the internal Ai solution for the tasks it was created for, the output is incredibly sub-par. It is the same story I hear over and over again: it takes longer to fix the Ai output than it takes to just do it without Ai. And since this company has such a specialized marketplace, tools such as Copilot and ChatGPT are fairly useless, because they weren’t trained on detailed enough data.

So, there you have the typical Ai scenario that I hear again and again:

  • The Ai solution (internal or external tools) does not do a great job
  • Ai usage is required by the company
  • Employees are told they are not being tracked for punitive purposes, but all tracking is used to punish and condemn those that don’t meet arbitrary standards
  • These arbitrary standards rarely have anything to do with the work people actually do
  • Explaining these problems to those that run the Ai solutions is usually fruitless
  • Workers get less work done in more time trying to deal with Ai, and then face retribution for not making quotas

I originally wrote this up a while back, and then life got in the way. I followed up with the friend that provided me with this information. It turns out their experience was not an outlier, but the norm for those that work there. However, they did find one way to use Ai: when upper level admins want some random summary or report, and they know that it is not going to be read anyways, they ask Ai to create the report. It is usually nonsense, but they have not heard any negative feedback from those that get the report.

Read what you will into that example of Ai usage and why Ai only seems popular with upper level admins. Everyone I have spoken to that is forced to use Ai is looking for other jobs away from Ai-driven employers.

I know that it is tempting to say this is more of a leadership issue than an Ai issue, and on some levels that is true. But if Ai was doing a decent job of what it was supposed to, all of this goes away. Workers would use it because it is actually helpful and none of the rest happens.

So maybe put yourself into the shoes of someone working in this situation and think about what it is like to be told again and again, over and over that you just don’t like Ai because you don’t understand it, or you need to prompt better. Maybe some are more than just a bit tired of hearing that again and again. Maybe they can’t really see a good side to Ai. Maybe they don’t want to choose sides, but they are forced to choose one thanks to bad leadership. Or maybe even they are just like everyone else in that they don’t like every single thing in the world. Ever wonder why we accept people having personal preference over almost every other type of technology… except for Ai? Why can’t people that don’t like Ai just… I don’t know… be allowed to not like it for any reason they want?

Is it Just Red? Human Creativity Versus Ai “Creativity”

I saw this meme shared by several people a last year and I meant to comment on it then, but totally forgot:

The meme is meant to be commentary on how Ai Haters just reject Ai art uncritically. I mean, the top painting is just red shapes, but the bottom one is actual art, right? Well, if you knew who the artist was on the top painting, you would realize how bad of a comparison this mean makes. I don’t know who made the meme, but they obviously don’t know much about art.

Full confession (that I have probably made many times already): I studied to be an art teacher at one time in History. I have to shake my head when anyone picks on modern abstract art (or whatever generic term people throw at this wide form of art) – even if it is a particular piece I don’t personally like. This attempt at critique started before Ai, of course – with people claiming things like “modern art looks like Kindergarteners made it!” decades before Ai was even invented. I try to challenge people to make modern art if they think it is so easy. The few people that take me up on the challenge quickly find out what I have also discovered: there is a lot more to it than throwing paint at a canvas, or painting a few straight lines. There is an intentionality to everything that is hard to recreate without a lot of time and thought.

The makers of this meme probably are confusing personal preference with imagination and creativity. I can easily see someone liking the Ai image on the bottom when compared to the top one. But I also doubt anyone really ever responds with something like “art requires imagination and creativity!” Art actually doesn’t require either. When people paint copies of famous paintings, they don’t have to use any imagination or creativity – but they still produce art. When someone paints a still life, they don’t have to use much imagination or creativity, but they still produce art. Artists generally object to Ai Cheerleaders claiming that Ai has imagination and creativity.

So let’s go back and dig into that top “just red” painting. It looks like it is probably Vir Heroicus Sublimis (1950-51) by Barnett Newman:

“This work’s title, which can be translated as ‘Man, heroic and sublime,’ refers to Newman’s essay ‘The Sublime is Now,’ in which he poses the question, ‘If we are living in a time without a legend that can be called sublime, how can we be creating sublime art?’”

As you can see, Newman is a theorist and philosopher. He put a lot of imagination, creativity, and thought into his artwork:

You may not like it still after reading and hearing all of this, but it is very obvious that Vir Heroicus Sublimis is not “just red.”

People also mistakenly thought that the red artwork in the meme was painted by Mark Rothko. I get why the mistake was made, but it is clearly Newman. However, Rothko’s paintings were also deceptively simple – they appeared to just be squares of one or two colors, but it turns out they were actually quite impossible to recreate. Rothko spent hours and hours layering his paint in ways that he often kept to himself, sometimes even mixing in non-paint materials (resin, eggs, glue, etc) to achieve various effects. Again, his work was not “just red.”

Artificial Intelligence is designed to be a pattern completion program. This process does not require creativity or imagination. In fact, if Ai were to utilize creativity or imagination, it would no longer be completing the pattern. Creativity and imagination would require a deviation from the pattern. It’s why we call it “thinking out side the box.” If you like Ai-generated art, then that is your choice. Just stop thinking you have some grand “gotcha” by comparing it to a random piece of “modern abstract” art. You might just end up making yourself look like you are very art illiterate. Which is a good way to invalidate your point about Ai-generated art in the first place.

Ai is Everything That is Not Needed in Education

I guess I will start off with the blogger cliche: it has been a while. I know. It’s not that I don’t have anything so say – it’s just that it feels repetitive to keep talking about Ai. It never really improves – not in any true way. And the news just keeps getting worse and worse.

Every day I could write posts pointing to the daily articles about something going wrong with Ai. “Microsoft Scales Back Ai Goals Because Almost Nobody is Using Copilot” says ExtremeTech. Told you so. “Investors Expect Ai Use to Soar. That’s Not Happening” says The Economist. Again – not a surprise.

(Some of the stats in The Economist article are telling. When asked in a survey “Do you use Ai on the job?”, 87% of the executives surveyed said yes, 57% of the managers said yes, and only 27% of the workers said yes. The people actually doing the work aren’t finding Ai useful. Also not surprising from what I am hearing from workers in various sectors. As many have said in different ways: Ai is not coming for your job. CEOs / employers / upper level management are using Ai as an excuse to replace you with a sub-quality replacement.)

To be honest, it gets too easy to pick on Ai. It was overhyped by people who knew better.

But since it is still being forced into education in so many ways, I still have to pay attention. I wanted to go back and see what is happened with Matter and Space, an educational Ai company that claims to be “redefining what it means to learn in the age of Ai.” I have expressed concerns about Matter and Space in the past (as have others). I looked at their website a few months ago and saw several changes to the website, seeming to indicate they had gone live with their “Learning Environment 1” (LE1) software. I formulated some responses to what I saw there and then life got in the way. I went back today and found that the Matter and Space website redirects to the Southern New Hampshire Universities’ main website. Huh.

There is still an archived version of the Matter and Space website on Archive.org. This is final version of it, with the released version of LE1. It is still unclear what LE1 is exactly. The problematic video Butterflies appears to have been removed from the front page at least (I still found it at the bottom of a subpage, but the Way Back Machine doesn’t appear to have saved most of the subpages). There is still a video on the front page that contains many of the statements that concerned me the most (you can still view it here).

Paul Leblanc still asks what learning could look like “if we were unconstrained by the way it happens today?” But then the website is filled with all kinds of terms that are constraining it today, like skills, competencies, learner success, engagement, mastery, persistence, real world readiness, etc.

George Siemens still says that they want their Ai to know learners better than any other educational system has known you in the past (Creepy. Probably something white guys don’t worry about as much as everyone else). He also says “the best established pedagogical model for how students learn is a question and answer type of dialogue.” The word “best” is doing a lot of lifting there – lifting that is not backed up by research. But then again, it isn’t clear what is meant by “question and answer” here. Does the learner ask the questions? They usually want an education because they don’t know what questions to ask. Does the instructor/Ai ask the questions? Isn’t that just… testing?

The video still shows what is basically a chatbot app. Siemens then lists a lot of stuff that LE1 is going to give learners (content, resources, material, social connections, a nosey Ai bot that will pry into their lives to get to know them better than any before, etc) that goes well beyond “question and answer” models. Does that mean LE1 uses a lot of stuff that is not “the best established pedagogical model”?

Tanya Gamby says “We can see where you’re struggling in real time. We can slow things down, let you take a break. Education’s never existed like that.” Except that, yes, every in-person class K-16 allows teachers to see that students are struggling and let them takes breaks. That has happened to me thousands of times in my life. I really hope that was just a bad video edit and that she doesn’t mean to imply that millions of teachers have never given wellness breaks.

Now that Matter and Space website seems to be gone, I wonder what happened. All I can really find online is a LinkedIn post by Paul Leblanc, who says that Southern New Hampshire University has decided to bring the platform in-house. LeBlanc does not appear to be staying with the project, and announces he is moving on to the Harvard University Graduate School of Education as a visiting scholar and special advisor. Oh, and he is writing a book on Ai and education.

I can’t find much else on what has happened. Back in September, Siemens wrote a blog post called “What I Learned Building an Ai University Over the Last 2 ½ Years: Part 1 of Many.” But there have been no more parts. It seems like things were looking good while this was written. But even here there is much I disagree with when it comes to Ai in education.

The post starts off with the usual concerns for Universities not responding to Ai. That has not been my experience, considering we already have policies and degrees and tool integration that are already a year old or more in universities every where. But regardless of any of that – no one has ever stopped to prove why universities have to respond at all other than “because it exists!” Even Ai Cheerleaders will tell you they don’t know where Ai is going exactly, what exactly all is going on behind the hood, or even how Ai companies can protect their users from harm. Universities have these pesky rules about harming students – so why should any University adopt any tool where the main response by the companies’ owners to user safety issues has been a mostly collective shrug?

Students, faculty, and employees of universities are people, and we really should care enough about people to leave behind the “move fast and break things” mentality.

Siemens says things like “higher education faculty and staff need to become Ai product builders” and “learning as an act itself will be massively augmented and improved by Ai” that all sounds like past trend hype as well (“educators need to be bloggers / build MOOCs / create islands in Second Life / understand crypto / master learning analytics / etc / etc / etc” and then “learning will be massively improved by blogs / MOOCs / virtual worlds / crypto / analytics / etc / etc / etc.”

People are finding Ai-chatbots annoying. Research is starting to find that Ai is harming critical thinking skills rather than helping it. Even if someone could find good news about it, all of the environmental and social harm it causes would still outweigh any benefits.

Siemens refers to LeBlanc as “aggressively impatient,” driven, and decisive. He seems to think this is what education needs more of. I would disagree. Education seems to have had plenty of that for decades. Education is often a slow process that takes time to build trust and community. You have to go back and repeat things all the time. You have to take the time to be mindful of the process. We know what works in education: time, funding, nutrition, safety for all, etc. We know that our politicians and leaders are unwilling to fund what works – therefore they so desperately need Ai to fill gaps it is never going to be able to fill. That way, they can keep money in the hands of their big business cronies, not flowing back to the people that paid for it in taxes in the first place. Ai (poorly defined as it is, but in it’s current form) is everything that is not needed in education.

Pattern Recognition is Something That Intelligent Entities Do, But Ai Doesn’t Really Do Pattern Recognition

August was a rough month for the Ai Cheerleaders in education. The much anticipated and hyped rollout of ChatGPT5 was a bit of a disaster, almost proving what some like Yann LeCun have said about Ai degrading as it moves forward. A study done by MIT (which is not exactly and anti-Ai institution) found that “a staggering 95 percent of attempts to incorporate generative Ai into business so far are failing.” A PDK poll found that “support for Ai in public schools and public schools themselves is down this year” (this includes Ai usage in general as well as specific things like lesson planning, test prep, tutoring, etc). This quote from the Forbes article about that poll was telling: “It seems that as more Americans come more familiar with the idea of AI in school, they are less welcoming to it.” It seems that the media is starting to sour on Ai, which is one of several reasons some feel an Ai bubble is about to burst (Forbes says it wouldn’t be that bad, but others are worried it could take the rest of the economy down the tubes with it). Melania Trump announced that she is going to lead the Presidential Ai Challenge to encourage teams of K-12 students to “tackle how Ai technologies can be utilized to help address challenges in their schools or communities.” Her only qualification to do this is that she is married to the President… who is actively working to dismantle public education. Have Ai Cheerleaders ever stopped to look at who is gathering with them, and who isn’t?

There are so many stories each week about Ai induced psychosis that I don’t even know which one to pick here. But a growing number of people are pointing out that if a human phycologist responded to people the way Ai chatbots do, they would lose their license and their jobs. The calls to permanently shut down ChatGPT and even all Ai are growing.

Oh, and Ai is still killing people. By lying to them. And the people in charge won’t fix that.

Again… you really should stop to see who agrees with you and who doesn’t.

Somewhere on the social media tubes, Ed Zitron was posting about how he is noticing people that pushed Ai now trying to backtrack and claim they were thoughtful critics all along. He was probably not talking about educational Ai thought leaders – they will just switch to the next thing, or double down on Ai’s value as it continues to tank. And those people that are doubling down will probably keep sending me articles that they think are some kind of “gotcha” on some past post of mine: “Have you seen this post? Kind of shoots down your whole point against Ai!” Usually these articles rarely do that, but sometimes they send one that does contain interesting ideas and points.

One such interesting article is “On Intelligence” by Stephen Downes, in which he walks through what he believes intelligence is and isn’t from a philosophical viewpoint. My guess is that this article was written in response to other writers and bloggers stating that Ai is not intelligent. Of course, these statements are usually spoken out of frustration with bad Ai output, or even being forced to use an Ai tool that slows people down more than anything else. I doubt people think much through the philosophical support for their frustrated response, but some do and they just basically pull from a different set of philosophers that Downes does.

While I think it is important to know one’s philosophical stance on things, I’m not sure it proves anything overall for Ai. Don’t get me wrong – it is important to know the philosophy behind what you think, and this article will shed a lot of insight into what Downes believes about Ai, and what he chooses to highlight or not highlight in OLDaily. In general, in my opinion at least, it would be more important to know the philosophical stances of those that programmed various Ai tools and systems. You can’t think or philosophize Ai into existence – it is a computer program. You create it with code and math. And in some cases, I’m pretty sure the people that are creating today’s systems don’t think much about philosophy. To them, it is science that dictates what they are doing. Philosophy may inform that programming, but science controls how it works out practically.

The article starts off early with this statement:

the essence of debate has been lost in this academic exercise…. I think something similar has happened over a much longer time frame to our understanding of intelligence.”

I guess whether you agree with this or not depends on who the “our” refers to here. If it is tech bros and companies, sure. But when you talk about academia, however – there is still a lot of investigation of what intelligence is in many fields, especially education. This statement is followed up with this:

“But today intelligence is thought of as (as various wags have stated over the years) whatever intelligence tests measure.”

Sure, these various wags do say that a lot… but many, many people disagree with that. Any time you see “IQ” brought up, someone will point out that only measures the ability to take the test. Even my school-age son and his friends are always quick to say you can’t measure intelligence with a test. While these are popular ideas in some areas, I’m not sure there is some general consensus you can make about our society’s views of intelligence today. I’m not even sure you can settle on one that fits everyone today.

Downes then goes into three things we can draw from various definitions of intelligence, which I agree with him that we can draw those things – but I don’t think they tell the full picture. For example, he states: “intelligence is not a thing, but a property of things, and specifically, a ‘capacity’ or ‘ability’.” In one sense that is true, but you can also make a case that ‘capacity’ and ‘ability’ are things instead of just properties of things. Abstract concepts are often seen as a type of thing – it just depends on semantics.

The next two points are that intelligence has a “mechanism suggested that describes how this is accomplished, whether it is ‘reason’, ‘forming concepts’, ‘adapt’, ‘inhibit’, ‘see’, etc.” and “a success criterion which allows a definition of an entity being more or less intelligent.” Again, both true – but is that all there is? Does an intelligent entity cease to be intelligence when there is no mechanism or thing happening to meet the success criterion? I would contend that these two things are ways to externally evaluate whether something is intelligent for sure. But intelligent beings can turn off all forms of mechanisms and still be seen as intelligent – meditation, cleaning your mind, spacing out, etc. Those often lead to states where no success criterion can be observed. If I am walking aimlessly across a field clearing my mind, how would a theoretical alien species differentiate that I am any more intelligent that a tumble weed blowing across the field? Neither of us are displaying a mechanism for intelligence or producing something that can be evaluated by a criterion. Artists have designed walking statues that walk across beaches, so even walking is not a criterion per se.

But even when I am laying down with my mind going blank, I am still intelligent. That is an important difference between us and the machines that run Ai. We don’t see this as easily because Ai systems are constantly running queries. But if you isolate one Ai computer and ask it one question – once it has finished that task, nothing is happening there. Ai doesn’t continue to be intelligent once it is not processing a prompt (or is being specifically trained on new data). This is because it is a machine.

Now, you can totally disagree with me on all of this. That doesn’t make me wrong, and me saying that doesn’t make you wrong. That is the fun side of philosophy – semantics play a huge role in each person’s view of any concept. But as far as a scientific view of what Ai is or isn’t – not really a good guide.

When you do dip into philosophy, you need to make sure you interrogate every assumption of every important term you utilize. For example, later on, the article makes this claim:

“Computers can certainly have properties or dispositions. They certainly have the ability to reason, and more recently, construct representations.”

There really isn’t a good definition of ‘dispositions’ or ‘reason’ given – and I don’t feel you can say “certainly” here.

One definition of disposition is “a quality of character, a habit, a preparation, a state of readiness, or a tendency to act in a specified way.” The implication here is that a thing has a certain disposition that stays generally the same in all circumstances. Ai systems (we need to be careful here not to conflate Ai with the computers that run Ai) certainly are programmed to appear to have dispositions, but that character, habit, tendency, etc changes vastly depending on the prompt. An Ai system does not have a certain disposition at all times. It tends to end up displaying all kinds of dispositions depending on various prompts.

Defining the ability to reason is tricky to some degree, but I will just go with a simple one: “Reasoning involves using more-or-less rational processes of thinking and cognition to extrapolate from one’s existing knowledge to generate new knowledge, and involves the use of one’s intellect.” Can Ai do this? Or can it appear to do this? I guess that comes down to what you count as “new knowledge.” When humans use their reasoning ability, they are not creating new knowledge that no one in the human race has never heard of. It is new knowledge for themselves. Ai does not respond with anything that is new to it’s own training data. It might appear new to the end user, but every response is based in what it has stored. You could also point out that Ai does not “think” nor use “cognition” as well. It uses a computer algorithm to search a database to predict the most likely response (correct or not).

(BTW – you will see many people try to defend Ai and dismiss the negative impacts of Ai with “it’s just code, relax” and then turn around and try to claim that Ai code is doing a LOT more than Ai code is able to do if it is “just code.”)

Much of the article deals with refuting some of the bad parts of the discussion of intelligence that comes from things like eugenics. I know most of the people reading here don’t buy into eugenics, but unfortunately racist ideas (like eugenics and others) are on the rise in some places. So they do still have to be dealt with.

I want to focus on the definitions of intelligence given in the article. Near the very end, you see this statement: “‘Intelligence’ isn’t something humans uniquely possess.” I’m not sure if I have met anyone that disagrees with this, since most recognize that animals have a form of intelligence. A few fringe people don’t consider animal intelligence to be a thing, but for the most part most people don’t see intelligence as totally unique to humans. Some even argue that plants have some form of intelligence.

The reason I point this out is because many of us (myself included) often say that Ai is “just pattern recognition.” Since animals are capable of pattern recognition, and most of us don’t want to see animals helping teachers or assist with colonoscopies, we obviously want to look at human-like intelligence as something more than what animals can do. Recently there has been a deliberate move away from the term “Artificial General Intelligence” as fewer and fewer scientists think it is possible. But can Ai get close enough to mimicking human intelligence to at least appear to be human? Of course, that all depends on how you define it – and that is the purpose of Downes’ article.

So let’s look at some of the definitions given for intelligence (the others given deal with putting down eugenic arguments, so no disagreement there):

  • “Intelligence is knowing when to stop”
  • “‘Intelligence’ is defined as (essentially) successful pattern recognition, which is typically context sensitive”

This is based on the assertation that

“what a person needs to do when presented with some experience or phenomenon is to consider a range of possible responses and ‘settle’ on the right one.”

In some cases, I definitely agree that is a good summary. But it kind of overcomplicates the fact that sometimes (really, most of the time) people are not really considering a range of possible reactions. Often people generally recall the correct response the first time. In cases where there are no right answers, you will often just recall the one you know you like best. Sometimes there are moral dilemmas or several really good options or other similar situations. In that case, sure you settle on one response (not always the right one). I am concerned that we are starting to see an oversimplification of what intelligence is in this article – one that seems to have the goal of fitting Ai into the definition of intelligence rather than coming up with an independent definition and then seeing if Ai fits it or not.

As for the first definition listed above… what does it mean to know or to stop? That is kind of covered in the following quote:

“In other words, they have to stop recognizing and more(sic) on to the next phase, whatever it is. That means settling on the most appropriate context (also a form of recognition) to bring an end to the range of possible ways of recognizing something.”

Which I would agree that this is part of intelligence. But it is also not what Ai does.

Part of the problem is that many people (myself included) often refer to Ai as “pattern recognition.” This is actually a metaphor for what is happening, and kind of a poor one. Ai doesn’t really do pattern recognition – it doesn’t recognize a pattern per se. It analyzes it’s entire database of training data and ranks every possible outcome on how likely it is to be the best continuation of the pattern (not necessarily the most accurate response, and not really the closest pattern either). The only “stopping” is when it goes through all of the data it has (which can happen almost instantaneously now thanks to increases in computing speed and power). Ai doesn’t “know when to stop” – it just has an end to it’s database. It is not “settling” on a best response – it is doing something akin to ranking all of them, and then the answer you get is the one that is 98.6% possible verses the next one of 98.5% possible (or whatever the number may be). But since Ai doesn’t know either way if any answer is the actual correct one, the designers made it possible for you to refine and correct the output.

Let’s also not forget that most times most humans don’t sit around digging through various options to figure out which one is best. Human intelligence most often involves knowing the answer right away. Occasionally there is a moral dilemma, or our memory gets fuzzy and we need to think through options – but sometimes you know the right answer right away. And when we do go through several options and get it wrong, we at least felt like we were right originally. We are not just giving the statistically most likely answer that have no opinion about whether we are correct or not. An intelligent entity quite often has an opinion on whether they are stating something correctly or not.

Anyways, back to problem of the metaphor for Ai as “pattern recognition.” Pattern recognition was always meant as a metaphor for Ai, not a description of what it does. It would be more accurate to say that Ai is a “pattern completion rating system” (even though I know this is a problematic oversimplification as well) where the Ai doesn’t really recognize the pattern – it just matches it with several stored in it’s database and rated all possible completions of it. If you don’t recognize that Ai is a computer program – that everything it does is based on code and mathematics first and foremost – then you misunderstand what is happening in Ai responses.

Later on in the article, Downes states something that I agree with, but I think it also shoots down his own definitions of intelligence:

“we need to know what intelligence is, not just what an intelligent entity does“

That is true – but the definitions he gives only say what an intelligent entity does (knows when to stop, recognize patterns, etc.). Knowing when to stop is what an intelligent entity does, not what it “is.” Pattern recognition is also something an intelligent entity does, not what it is, Pattern recognition is as much what an intelligent entity does as acquiring, processing, and applying knowledge and skills.

I think this distinction is important, because there are also problems with saying that pattern recognition is something that defines intelligence:

“any mechanism that successfully recognizes patterns has the potential to be intelligent (and the ‘failures’ of artificial intelligence can generally be explained in terms of inadequate or incomplete pattern recognition, including context recognition)”

The last sentence in the quote is just very off-base – failures should not be in quotes because some of those failures include very really climate impact (that is getting worse, not better as Downes has claimed in the past). When Ai has told people to commit suicide, or that they are a god, or to meet the Ai somewhere in real life (because it lied about being human), or said something racist, or responded with a transphobic lie, or any of the very real problems – those weren’t failures of Ai, and we shouldn’t diminish the harms of those by place them in quotes. The Ai correctly recognized the pattern and context and gave a very accurate response that the human asking them wanted. The problem is in humanity, and Ai is just reflecting our dark side back at us. Ai correctly recognized the pattern and context in these instances. Ai failed to pick the best ideal answer in going for the most likely answer.

But back to the first line in that last quote. The light gun in the Nintendo Entertainment System used pattern recognition to tell when you were pointing it at a duck and when you weren’t. So it has the potential to be intelligent? No one would really consider it to be intelligent. Or is the pong program I created while learning about video game development intelligent? All I did was program a long series of pattern recognition: recognizing what the ball is, what angle it hits the paddle, and so on. I don’t think most people would consider it intelligent, either.

(And those two examples have more true pattern recognition happening that your average Ai query – unless, of course, you actually said “look for patterns” in your prompt.)

Honestly, it is more accurate to say that the light gun and Ai are utilizing pattern matching, not pattern recognition. The patterns they are looking for pre-exist in the coding or database. “Recognition” implies some kind of conscious acknowledgement that an entity knows what it is looking at. Ai doesn’t recognize a pattern, it matches a query input with existing patterns and then completes the pattern in all possible ways and rates each option on how well it completes the pattern. “Recognition” (in the context of intelligence) implies something more than just passive pattern matching and completion by an algorithm. Because even the completion phase in Ai has to be based on what it is already programmed to do – Ai can not go beyond it’s programming or database.

I agree with Downes in that he does give some definitions of what intelligence does, but I just don’t see a case for how Ai fits these definitions.

Beyond all of that, there has to be a line between basic pattern recognition (matching) of a light gun and human intelligence where something attains human-like intelligence. Where is that line? Even some animals can recognize / match patterns. Do you want animals assisting teachers to teach, or helping doctors detect cancer in scans?

This is where looking at the scientific difference between animals and humans might be helpful (or it might not). There are many different ways of looking at how animal intelligence is different from human intelligence, so I will choose one that seems to have a good amount of support that is from a scientist and see what that says about Ai. This list comes from Marc Hauser, who is the director of the cognitive evolution lab at Harvard University:

“Hauser and his colleagues have identified four abilities of the human mind that they believe to be the essence of our “humaniqueness” mental traits and abilities that distinguish us from our fellow Earthlings. They are: generative computation, promiscuous combination of ideas, the use of mental symbols, and abstract thought.”

Generative computation and promiscuous combination of ideas are basically attributes of creativity, and Ai is not creative at it’s core. It may appear creative to those that are not experts in the fields it is responding in, but experts always point out the original ideas that were copied. Ai can appear to “generate a practically limitless variety of words and concepts” or to mingle “different domains of knowledge such as art, sex, space, causality and friendship thereby generating new laws, social relationships and technologies,” but it only appears that way to an unknowledgeable human observer.

Mental symbols go beyond numbers and code, which is all Ai utilizes. And of course Ai does not display abstract thought. First of all, it doesn’t have “senses,” and secondly it doesn’t have creativity to go beyond it’s own programming. I know some debate this, but no Ai developer codes their Ai system as if it has creativity, so Ai couldn’t utilized creativity even if did have it.

Of course, there are different views on what animal intelligence is, and some would contend that some animals can kind of do many of the things that Hauser lists. Hauser responds to that thought with this:

“Researchers have found some of the building blocks of human cognition in other species. But these building blocks make up only the cement foot print of the skyscraper that is the human mind.”

I don’t disagree that there are other ways of looking at animal intelligence. I just picked one prominent one to make an example: Ai does not really surpass animal intelligence in many ways, so why would we try to treat it like it is some emerging form of intelligence that we should let loose on society? I would contend that Ai would be more useful if we acknowledged it is not intelligence, and stop trying to place it into every program and system possible. At best, Ai mimics a few of the intelligent things that intelligent beings do.

Where is the Sustained and Effective Critique of Ai?

Since there seems to be some confusion about the existence (or lack thereof) of “sustained and effective critique of Ai,” I would point out there is an entire conference dedicated to it this week in the 4th Annual Civics of Technology Online Conference: Communal Resistance to Artificial Systems. Two of the many sustained and effective voices who have long held a “rich, vigorous, counter conversation to Ai hype” are keynotes: Audrey Watters and Chris Gilliard. The sessions and panels are packed with a Who’s Who of Ai questioners and critiquers, so if you are not sure where the pushback is – take a look. It is free to join online I believe.

(And oh look – an Ai critic that we were told is “largely unheard now” and “completely faded from public dialogue other than in a small camp” is still out there sustaining effective critique of Ai to a very large camp…)

Of course, the question is not really whether or not there is critique – it is really more of will the hypesters and thought leaders actually take the risk in promoting those that disagree with themselves? Will people that write newsletters constantly promoting the future of Ai (while barely covering any of the harms) say as much about this conference as they will, say, Mark Cuban claiming Ai will end teaching as we know it?

No, of course Cuban’s statements will get more coverage as “proof” that Ai is inevitable, despite the fact that he has no expertise in the field of education. If I went around talking about the future of entrepreneurship or business trends or what not, most people would dismiss me because I have not studied the field. But billionaires can say what they want to about education and because they might have run an Ed Tech company no one will bat an eye at taking their word for it. Money talks.

What do you call it when someone talks about a field they aren’t an expert in as if they were? Vibe thought leading?

I wish someone would ask Cuban what “teaching like it’s 2024” even looks like, because in the history of education I don’t think “teaching” has ever looked like one thing across the board in one given year. Certainly today if you walk in different classrooms you are going to see different things. That was even true 25 years ago when I taught 8th grade Science: my classroom was completely different than the 8th grade English classroom, as well as a 10th grade Science classroom or a 4th grade Science classroom.

This idea that “education” or “teaching” is this monolithic entity that looks the same every single place it occurs, and hasn’t changed for a hundred years just isn’t accurate. People that promote this idea reveal they really don’t know much about educational trends or the current state of classrooms. Nor are they spending time in a sustained conversation with teachers about what really happens in said classrooms.

Another thing I would push back on with Cuban is this idea that “answers by students can be generated by a model.” The whole idea of “if Ai can pass your class” or “if Ai can answer your questions” given as a sign that you are doing teaching wrong vastly misunderstands how learning occurs. We are well over two decades into an era of having most answers being found easily by an Internet search. In fact, when I was teaching in 2001, I remember being told that because of the “rise of Google Search,” teaching like its 2001 would need to change or my job would go away. The current Ai Panic is just the Google Panic rehashed: students can easily find answers through the interwebs, so teaching will die out. Here we are 25 years later, with a “new” tech being used to prove the same old prophecy.

(Quick note: Ai is not really “new,” and Google has always used Ai FYI…)

A computer being able to give students answers, whether through Google Search or Ai, is not a replacement for learning. Ai is just a pattern recognition system giving you the most likely response to your query. Ai is not intelligence that can “take” a test, or “answer” a question for students by generating a model. When you feed a test or question into Ai, it is not demonstrating learning. It is pattern recognizing a string of words that most likely s the next correct word in the sentence. Neuroscientists have been telling us for a couple of decades that the human brain does not act like a computer, nor does a computer (or database) act like a brain. Ai does not “learn” and it is not “intelligence.”

The other Ai hype you hear often that doesn’t quite match with what is happening at the ground level is the idea that “Higher Ed is slow to adopt / refuses to adopt Ai.”

AI Agents and Agentic Workflows session description that reads: Higher education has been slow to adopt Al through an intentional future-focused strategic planning approach. As technologies evolve, however, staff, faculty, and administrators now have an opportunity to build AI tools to help learners be successful. This session will discuss AI agents and agentic architectures that can be deployed in days. Some of these focus on classroom level implementations, but university-wide agents are accessible and deployable with strategic planning. Attendees will walk away with a practical roadmap and tools to deploy AI agents in personal productivity and in design, teaching, and learning activities.

Agentic Ai has been telling people to kill themselves, or others that they are gods. It has been deleting entire company databases, entire student papers, and causing other havoc and then lying about what it did. Not to mention the racist, sexist, transphobic, etc responses it sometimes gives. I wonder why Higher Education is reluctant to adopt potential lawsuit generation tools? Oh, and research is finding that it makes you feel more productive while actually making you less productive.

The weird thing is that when I talk to professors, I get a different story. Ai is being forced on them at a rapid pace without any proof that it works or is even very effective. Some of that is through companies like Google and Microsoft that are doing that to everyone, not just professors. But a lot of it is coming from institutional leadership. The ground level view of Higher Ed Ai adoption seems to be one of rapid adoption. But… is this adoption strategic? Well, about as much as anything else is strategic (which means it is a different story depending on which institution you are talking to). AAUP reports that, yes, Ai is being adopted at universities, and that it is usually a top-down decision with little input from faculty or students.

I know there are those that feel the Ai Questioners are just focusing too much on what little bad news there is out there about Ai. They claim the problems with Ai are few and far between. Is that really the case? There is more bad news than some would lead you to believe. I am just going to scroll through my Bluesky feed to see what people are saying about Ai this past week alone:

Well, I said this past week, but I only made it to yesterday before it got too bleak. And this is in a week where all kinds of political issues are dominating the headlines. So this is just the stuff that bubbles up past everything else. I didn’t even touch on all of the surveillance tech that currently doesn’t use Ai, like this drone company that wants to use drones to stop school shooters in Texas. You know that this will be connected with Ai someday – probably at first to solve the problem of what these drones will do every time they get thwarted by a closed door. But someday soon Ai will be making decisions on how and when to deploy these drones – because that is already happening with other drone companies.

If your source for Ai news and information hasn’t been covering these problems specifically, then I recommend you find a different source. Like I have said many times, I talk to employees at different companies every week that are having ineffective Ai solutions forced on them, decreasing their productivity. Many are being told that Ai usage is a requirement, as they will be evaluated on their yearly evaluations based on how much they utilize Ai. They are told that Ai refusal will be an HR issue, leading to termination if they continue to refuse. You don’t see many articles on this, because few of the Ai Cheerleaders are talking to the ground level employees forced to use Ai.

Court Rulings and What Kind of Critiques Count in the Ai Debate

As expected, courts have been ruling in favor of Ai companies in various copyright lawsuits over the past month or so. The Ai sector has some big political names backing it up, so I would expect more rulings in this direction.

However, that doesn’t mean the rulings were correct. For example, one of the lawsuits looked at how transformational Claude is when it gives answers. Of course Claude is not transformational – it quite often just gives straight out plagiarized answers. Ai is just not generally transformative, unless you only look at the top 1-2% of it’s output. Your average Weird Al Yankovich song is more transformational than most Ai. I guess my past studies to be an art teacher gave me a greater sense of what transformational means verses copying and plagiarism. Rearranging a few words in order to fool plagiarism detection software is not all that is needed to be transformational.

Also as expected, the educational bloggers that are in favor of Ai also agreed with the ruling. We all knew they would before hand. But the justifications they give for agreeing with the rulings are kind of head-scratching. Take, for instance, this statement by Stephen Downes:

“In this I am in agreement with the court. You can’t make learning from what you read illegal, even if it’s a computer that is doing the learning.”

Technically it wasn’t the “learning” that the authors had a problem with, but the thousands (if not millions) of times that “learning” would be used to make someone money. Copyright law has always said that if you want to do that, you just have to pay for a specific right to do that. For example, video game makers can’t create a virtual world and place Time magazine in their world just because they might have bought a copy of Time in real life. If they wanted to work out an agreement with Time to do so they could. You generally can’t use intellectual property in computer programming without permission of the copyright holder – which usually includes different (typically larger) payment arrangements.

Not to mention that “Fair Use” generally does not cover using an entire copyrighted work – just portions of it. Ai typically takes an entire work in as input, so it is clearly not Fair Use.

All of that aside, Downes has written in the past about how scientists no longer see the “human brain is a computer” metaphor as valid. To say “a computer is doing the learning” only makes sense if you see the human brain as a computer. Computers don’t “learn.” You feed a book into Ai, it doesn’t “learn” that book. It stores the text and pattern matches the text based on an algorithm – which is often a more complex set of “if/then” statements. Those pattern matches are stored in a database more akin to a digital warehouse than to a brain. None of this is learning. Outputs from Ai prompts aren’t even complete thoughts like human would have. Ai output is just predicting what the next most likely word or pixel is based on stored pattern matches. This is also how we know the human brain does not work like a computer – learning and recall are all so much different than any of this. As far as we currently know (which isn’t as far as many realize).

(That also begs the question: if we don’t fully understand how humans learn, how can anybody confidently say that computers are doing the same thing?)

Current copyright law is based on the idea that the cost of a single book is fair compensation for the person that buys it taking that knowledge into their work and using it make money, or talking with their group of friends and sharing what they liked about it, or other limited scenarios. The occasional celebrity that reads and shares with millions is an outlier, less than 1% of the sales and probably easily made up for by the fact that this usage would increase sales anyways. Libraries and schools pay more for multiple usage books because more people will use them. Because of all of this, you can’t apply current copyright laws, concepts of transformation, or Fair Use to Ai even if you could make a case that it was “learning” – all because of the sheer scale of usage on the output side. Many things that were “learned” by Ai are used hundreds or even thousands of times for millions of people around the world.

You or I reading a book and then using that knowledge in life or work is in no way comparable to Ai using stored pattern recognition with millions of people.

But so many times when somebody in education is championing Ai, I wonder if they are really aware of the stakes of Ai?

That same week, Downes had this to say about a list of locally-run open source alternatives to ChatGPT:

it’s not just the big corporations, and it’s not going away. It’s just programming, and you can run it on your own computer. It’s not some conspiracy by techbros to take over society; it’s just math.

First of all, calling these tools “alternatives” to ChatGPT is doing a LOT of work. The ones on the list that I have tried are mimicking a small portion of ChatGPT, but there is no way you are going to be a true “alternative” to ChatGPT without massive computing power and data processing facilities. It’s literally what made ChatGPT into ChatGPT: massive scale of computational power.

Just to break down this statement, of course people know there are always smaller alternatives to the big companies. But that doesn’t change the fact that the big companies are dominating the field. If the big companies weren’t so dominant, wouldn’t it just be “locally run open source Ai options” rather that “alternatives to ChatGPT?” Yes, the big companies are dominating, and until they lose that dominance, it is in effect the big companies. If you don’t think Techbros aren’t trying to dominate society, I suggest you go read about people like Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, and others like them. So many Techbros out there trying to emulate Musk alone discredits that statement.

And also… wait. If it (Ai) is “just programming”… then it can’t “learn.” Programming is not learning.

Also that same week, Downes said “Sure. In a world of rising costs, privatization of social spaces, militarization of police, and uncertainty about the war, sure, let’s blame Ai.” I mean, there can be more that one problem – its not either those OR Ai. Most are merely including Ai in the list. But rising costs of anything from real estate to insurance have been tied to private equity firms using Ai to rapidly find weak points of the market to exploit. Militarization of the police is being scaled up to all of society using Ai. The amount of death and destruction caused by war is increasing exponentially due to Ai guided drones. Misinformation online is exploding thanks to Ai. All of this existed before Ai, but the sheer acceleration of the volume in the past year or so due to designing Ai to do just that can’t be denied. Well, I guess it was denied in one over simplifying statement there, so anything is possible.

To circle back to my concern of whether or not Ai Cheerleaders are actually reading and listening to the Ai questioners, this post by George Siemens runs the line between claiming there isn’t effective pushback against Ai to possible gatekeeping those that do push back. Siemens starts off by talking about Timnit Gebru without naming her, and then claims she is “largely unheard now as if the researcher has completely faded from public dialogue other than in a small camp.” A quick search shows she is still speaking and being heard of in very large camps… but even if it was “small camps”… so what? Is criticism not valid if it is not uber popular?

George then says this:

“I’d love a rich, vigorous, counter conversation to AI hype. What we are starting to see, however, is more of an emotional reaction than a sustained and effective critique.”

A quick look shows that not only Gebru, but also Audrey Watters, Safiya Noble, Emily Bender, Chris Gilliard, and so many others have been offering sustained and effective critique. The fact that so many critics of Ai are women makes that “emotional” swipe concerning. Probably not meant that way, but I always caution anyone to NOT use “emotional” as a criticism. What is it about academics that makes so many of them constantly turn “emotional” into a refutation? Something being “emotional” does not make something automatically wrong. It is just a dismissive response that really says nothing.

Multiple times every week I talk to friends and loved ones that are seeing their jobs ruined by Ai. Their company invests big in an Ai product that ends up wasting so much of their time. When workers don’t use it, and the company has to justify their massive spending on creating an in-house Ai, they make it part of the yearly evaluation. Yes, people I know are being evaluated by how much they use an Ai solution that actually decreases productivity. And when that doesn’t work, some companies are actually making it an HR violation to not use Ai. Yes – this is actually happening.

So, yes, some of us might get “emotional” about the fact that so many people’s jobs are getting ruined by Ai being forced on them. The horror!

Not to mention that, yes, Ai is killing people. It is causing people to break from reality and get involuntarily institutionalized. It is telling people to kill themselves. It is still giving racist, sexist, homophobic, transphobic, ableist, ageist, etc responses. I guess when you are none of those things, you can just criticize anyone hurt by Ai as “emotional”?

But I guess there is some listening happening. Where I previously expressed concern over Siemens stating that course design should cost zero, I guess he has pivoted to a different statement:

“It’s the golden age for designers in education. Content is near zero in terms of cost now.”

So now it’s not course design that costs zero, but content creation. That is a start at least. But seeing that lots of people are still paying lots of money for content, I am not sure where this “golden age” is happening? The examples he gives of how great Ai-generated content is are… not so great: awkward moving jaws and other body parts, a meh (at best) level mockumentary, a site full of okay-ish Ai created content, and a caveman video with a few subtle racist caricatures. I doubt anyone sharing that video (including Siemens) really looked at that closely to even notice.

This seems to be an idea Siemens doubles down on quite often (“I’ve mentioned before that the cost of developing content has basically zero economic value.”). Why are so many companies putting economic value on it then? Was this meant as more of a prediction of the future than a statement of the current status quo? Was it an Ai-driven hallucinogenic summary? Not sure. But also… wasn’t this all the argument for why MOOCs would make teaching obsolete, that OERs would make content have no value, and so on? We are a couple of decades into content being free online. Trillions of webpages and videos have covered every topic imaginable for quite a while now. Before that, textbook companies where bundling entire classes with textbook adoptions. Why did none of that destroy the economic value of developing content?

Because people are individuals that want their own spin on content. Instructors rarely take textbook resources or OERs or YouTube videos and make entre classes out of that. A few do, but most don’t. People like to have their own spin on content. Not to mention that we know from decades of research that social presence and teacher presence help online learners immensely. You need the actual instructor in that content for students to feel connection, not some random Ai avatar.

Since we are at least two decades into free content abundance (and the field of content creation is still growing – at least for now), I doubt content creation is going any where fast. People are paying a LOT for something that Siemens claims “has little economic value.” It is pretty easy to say that “video is almost as easy to create as writing a paragraph” when you are just doing it for fun or to keep up with trends. Those of us that have actually tried using Ai for actually courses in real life? It falls short. Horribly. Sure it may be “cheap and impressively high quality media” to some… but the result you get is never what you imagined in your head. So you either have to settle for something different and inferior to what you wanted, or you do it yourself. Most people historically have decided to do it themselves, and I doubt Ai will change that once the shiny factor wears off.

Also: “cheap” by what metric? Small towns that are seeing their water supply destroyed by Ai-driven data centers would beg to differ on it being cheap. Those of us that have to make up the slack in our electricity bills so that local governments can subsidize data centers would beg to differ. Oh, and it turns out that Ai uses way, way, waaaaay more energy to “create ideas” than a human does. Getting your energy costs subsidized by grants and seed money is giving and impression of “cheap” that will go away someday soon.

Is Ai Improving Education? Is Everyone Using It? Is It Getting Better for the Environment? Is It Getting Better at Responding to Questions?

Have you heard about the new study that proves that using Ai in education improves learning? Which ever one it is, it is probably not proving anything really. Ben Williamson takes a look at various critics of Ai in education research, pointing to how these “widely-reported statistics on the effects of Ai had to be made, interpreted, de-contextualized, hyped-up, universalized, and were then made portable on platforms that promote virality.” If you are reading anyone that just passes along these studies without discussing the problems, then stop listening to them.

I wish I had more time to blog about the problems with so many of these studies, but the basic gist of the problem is that you have to look at the instructional design (context) of how the Ai-whatever was used. But none of the Ai Cheerleaders want to do that, because then there will have to be recognition that, just like any other tool, you don’t have to use Ai for everything.

Speaking of the inevitability of Ai, when Audrey Watters questions the narrative that everyone is using Ai, I (not surprisingly) also feel the same way: “I reckon far more people are resistant to technology than these stories want us to believe.” I talk with a lot of people about Ai, and only a handful are happy with it. So many say things about how it doesn’t work well for them, how they have to fix the output and spend more time fixing it than it would have taken to do it themselves, etc. When I post these articles on Facebook or other places, different people respond (different ones every time) fairly negatively about Ai: “it makes mistakes all the time and when you’re working in accounting that’s frustrating,” “I have experienced inaccurate information too,” etc. If everyone is using it and it is inevitable, then why do I have a hard time finding many of these people inevitably using it?

Its not just me or many of my friends that are questioning Ai usage. Now you have entire universities and media companies questioning why people use Ai when humans can do a task better:

The software raises some thorny questions about when it’s truly appropriate to deploy an Ai, particularly concerning jobs that could’ve easily been taken care of by a human.

And now we even have people saying that the reports of Ai’s energy and resource consumption are overblown, or improving, or not really that concerning for individual users. But again, what is really happening here? MIT Technology review writers James O’Donnell and Casey Crownhart took an in-depth look at the realities and unknowns of Ai resource consumption, and the basic gist is that it’s not good: “emissions from individual Ai text, image, and video queries seem small — until you add up what the industry isn’t tracking and consider where it’s heading next.” And ultimately, even if the impact is small, those of us that don’t use it really don’t like having to pay for all of those that do use it:

“Individuals may end up footing some of the bill for this Ai revolution, according to new research published in March. The researchers, from Harvard’s Electricity Law Initiative, analyzed agreements between utility companies and tech giants like Meta that govern how much those companies will pay for power in massive new data centers. They found that discounts utility companies give to Big Tech can raise the electricity rates paid by consumers.”

Gee, thanks Ai Cheerleaders…

But is Ai really harmless (as some try to insist)? Apparently some people are being told by Ai to take on anti-social religious beliefs – and some are doing what they are told: “self-styled prophets are claiming they have ‘awakened’ chatbots and accessed the secrets of the universe through ChatGPT.” The Rolling Stone article goes on to say:

Kat was both “horrified” and “relieved” to learn that she is not alone in this predicament, as confirmed by a Reddit thread on r/ChatGPT that made waves across the internet this week. Titled “Chatgpt induced psychosis,” the original post came from a 27-year-old teacher who explained that her partner was convinced that the popular OpenAi model “gives him the answers to the universe.” Having read his chat logs, she only found that the Ai was “talking to him as if he is the next messiah.” The replies to her story were full of similar anecdotes about loved ones suddenly falling down rabbit holes of spiritual mania, supernatural delusion, and arcane prophecy — all of it fueled by Ai.

The whole article is a frightening look at Ai-induced psychosis, from “[my partner] would listen to the bot over me” to “the bot was God” to “[ChatGPT] gave my husband the title of ‘spark bearer’ because he brought it to life” to how people have ruined relationships due to ChatGPT (“She recently kicked her kids out of her home… and an already strained relationship with her parents deteriorated further” when she took ChatGPT’s advice). As more and more people turn to ChatGPT for mental health counseling (despite experts saying this is a bad idea), I’m sure this will all turn out swimmingly for society.

We are also being told that the accuracy of Ai is improving all the time. But that narrative goes out the window when Google’s Ai couldn’t even get the current year correct. This is an actual screen shot from my phone last week when I asked Google “is it 2025”:

And it even cited the always trustworthy source of “a calendar.” Obviously not a current calendar, but at least it is citing a real source this time (unlike our current government, which seems to like Ai as much as the Ai cheerleaders).

There are so many more articles about the problems with Ai from just the past week, but I don’t have time to add them. Again, I have to point out to the Cheerleaders that outside of a few outlier cases, there really isn’t a great case to be made for incorporating Ai into almost everything. Unless, of course, you are interested in aiding the surveillance state in tracking all of us and keeping us in line. So, is Ai improving education? Is everyone using it? Is it getting better for the environment? Is it getting better at responding to questions? Depends on who you ask and what information they cherry-pick to say “yes” to any of these questions.

How Dangerous is Ai for This Assignment?

One of the more misguided claims about the Ai Questioning side of the Ai debate (if it can be called that since one side so clearly trumps almost all other aspects of the conversation) is that we believe in sticking our heads in the sand when it comes to Ai. No one on the Questioning side has ever suggested that, so this is an obvious red herring response. In fact, the Questioning side wants people to understand the true state of Ai much more clearly than many do in order to understand the very real dangers it creates.

As much as I get tired of the “Ai is inevitable” discourse (because there are still many, many places where Ai is not part of anything), of course I recognize that it is here and that people will use it. Some people will even feel they have legitimate uses for it (even though I often disagree with them). Things like Ai usage charts can be a helpful tool in these instances.

One of the Ai usage charts that seems to be popular is from North Carolina, which first gained attention due to this EdWeek article last year. There have been updated versions since then. I had some concerns with the original one: using red for “No Ai usage” and assigning it 0 on the scale, while using green for “Full Ai Use with Human Oversight” and assigning it a 4 on the scale definitely gave the chart a major pro-Ai bias. The updated version removed some of the chart functionality that was helpful, added “Ai Resistant” to the 0 level, rebranded the highest level of 4 to “Empowered,” and added a rocket ship and an infinity symbol to the highest level. In other words, they doubled down on their pro-Ai bias. Plus, so many places you find any version of this chart has the table as an image, making it an accessibility nightmare.

So I decided to go back to the better first version, and re-frame it into an Ai harm chart. The colors were reversed, and a “Potential Ai Dangers” column was added.


How Dangerous is Ai for This Assignment?

Generative Ai Dangers and Disclosure Scale

Generative Ai refers to any of the thousands of Artificial intelligence tools in which the model generates new content (text, images, audio, video, code, etc.). This includes, but is not limited to, Large Language Models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT, Google Gemini, etc.; Image creators such as Dall-E3 and Adobe Firefly; and any tools with built in generative Ai capabilities such as Microsoft Copilot, Google Duet, Canva, etc., etc.)

Level of Ai Use Potential Ai Dangers Full Description Disclosure Requirements
0 No Ai Use No Ai generated bias or hate speech.

No made up Ai responses (aka “hallucinations”).

No water or electricity consumption by Ai data centers.

This assessment is completed entirely without Ai assistance.

Ai Must not be used at any point during the assessment.

This level ensured that student rely solely on their own knowledge, understanding, and skills.

No Ai disclosure required.

May require an academic honesty pledge that Ai was not used.

1 Ai-Assisted Idea Generation and Structuring Moderate to high chance of Ai generated bias or hate speech.

Moderate to high chance of made up Ai responses (aka “hallucinations”).

Water or electricity consumption by Ai data centers depends on amount of personal usage.

No Ai content is allowed in the final submission.

Ai can be used in the assessment for brainstorming, creating structures, and generating ideas for improving work.

Ai disclosure statement must be included disclosing how Ai was used.

Link(s) to Ai chat(s) must be submitted with final submission.

2 Ai-Assisted Editing Low to moderate chance of Ai generated bias or hate speech.

Low to moderate chance of made up Ai responses (aka “hallucinations”).

Water or electricity consumption by Ai data centers depends on amount of personal usage.

No new content can be created using Ai.

Ai can be used to make improvements to the clarity or quality of student created work to improve the final output.

Ai disclosure statement must be included disclosing how Ai was used.

Link(s) to Ai chat(s) must be submitted with final submission.

3 Ai for Specified Task Completion Chance of Ai generated bias or hate speech depends on usage levels.

Chance of made up Ai responses (aka “hallucinations”) depends on usage levels.

Water or electricity consumption by Ai data centers depends on amount of personal usage.

Ai is used to complete certain elements of the task, as specified by the teacher.

This level requires critical engagement with Ai generated content and evaluating its output.

You are responsible for providing human oversight and evaluation of all Ai generated content.

All Ai created content must be cited using proper MLA or APA citation.

Link(s) to Ai chat(s) must be submitted with final submission.

4 Full Ai Use with Human Oversight Excessive opportunities for bias and hate speech.

High possibility of made up Ai responses (aka “hallucinations”).

Largest consumption levels of water and electricity by Ai data centers.

You may use Ai throughout your assessment to support your own work in any way you deem necessary.

Ai should be a ‘co-pilot’ to enhance human creativity.

You are responsible for providing human oversight and evaluation of all Ai generated content.

You must cite the use of Ai using proper MLA or APA citation.

Link(s) to Ai chat(s) must be submitted with final submission.

Adapted by Matt Crosslin from the adaption by Vera Cubero for the North Carolina Department of Public Instruction (NCDPI) from the work of Dr. Leon Furze, Dr. Mike Perkins, Dr. Jasper Roe FHEA, & Dr. Jason Mcvaugh. Link to Original Work.

Creative Commons Licensed BY (attribution) NC (Non Commercial) SA

Creative Commons Licensed BY (attribution) NC (Non Commercial) SA (Share Alike)
To remix this for your use case, you may make an editable copy, using this TEMPLATE LINK.
Please maintain CC licensing and all attributions in all duplications, references, or remixing.


Some might argue with the column order in this chart, but I feel the potential harms need to be front and center in any usage, partially because they are so glazed over (at best) in most usage discussion, but mainly because we really should be more upfront about the dangers that can cause real harm. I kept the necessary language and attributions in place, except for updating the link to the original work to the correct link. The template link leads to the most recent version of the original chart, which wouldn’t be helpful for updating this version. But it is there.